Monday, May 17, 2010
Health Food vs Healthier Food: Trying the White House Fruit and Oat Bars.
Most of the time, I try to eat “well” and prepare “healthy” food for my family. That means lots of fruits and vegetables, not much red meat and using whole grains instead of “white” grains. But everyone in my house enjoys a good dessert, including me.
Usually, when it comes to dessert, my philosophy is to go at the preparation without holding anything back – that means cream and butter when called for and sugar. Because as far as I’m concerned, dessert isn’t dessert without a sugar of some kind (and that includes maple sugar, honey and brown sugar, not just the good ol’ white stuff). And I don’t feel guilty about this because we keep our portions small and dessert is an occasional treat, not a nightly occurrence.
So I was intrigued when reading about the White House Pastry Chef , Bill Yosses, in the New York Times (story/recipe). Yosses has a formidable task as pastry platters seem to be present at every meeting in the White House. And because the White House is home to two VIK’s (Very Important Kids), Yosses tried to create a kid friendly sweet treat to replace cookies. The result is a granola-like fruit and oat bar.
Granola is certainly no health food – it has plenty of sugar on top of the oats and dried fruit. But it is healthier food – an alternative to a cookie or cupcake when you want something sweet with a bit less guilt.
So I decided to give Yosses’ recipe a whirl and have it taste-tested by two very different audiences – my toddler and husband, who are both very traditional when it comes to dessert (i.e. a dessert should clearly be dessert) and a small dinner party of public health professionals.
Yosses’ recipe has several opportunities for adaptation so here’s what I did after prepping my 9 inch square baking pan with oil brushed parchment.
Toasted 2 c of rolled oats with ½ cup of pumpkin and sesame seeds in the oven at 350 for 8 minutes. My seed blend was mostly pumpkin seeds.
Chop up 1 ½ c of dried fruit.
Mine was a mix of apricots
Dried blueberries, dried mission figs and candied ginger
After the oats and seeds were done, I tossed them with the dried fruit and 1 teaspoon of ground cardamom.
Combine in a saucepan ½ c honey, 1/3 c dark brown sugar, 1/3 c maple syrup, pinch of salt and 6 T of canola oil and stir until combined and sugar is dissolved.
Pour over the oat, seed, fruit mix and stir to combine.
Spread in the pan and even the top.
Bake for 25 minutes. Remove from oven and place on rack to cool completely.
Using paper overhang, remove from pan and cut into bars.
The bars were pretty sticky and hard to cut, but the bits that stuck to the paper tasted pretty good. The cardamom flavor was a nice break from the usual granola flavors but a bit strong. When I sampled the final product, I liked it. It certainly isn’t going to bring the same result in a dinner party guest as those whoopie pies I made last month, but these have some redeeming value, and Chef Yosses’ goal wasn’t to make a decadent dessert. I’m sure his whoopie pies would put mine to shame.
My daughter was very excited that mama was baking, but when I handed her a bite she looked puzzled. While she loves fresh blueberries and will eat close to her body weight in one sitting after a normal sized meal, she has never been a fan of blueberries IN other food – blueberry bagels are not appealing, nor are blueberries in pancakes. She took one look and asked if the bar had blueberries in it. When I confirmed her suspicion, she asked me to remove them. As you can probably guess from the pictures above, that isn’t really feasible. When informed of this, she handed the bar back and went back to her coloring book. My husband had a slightly better response – he at least tried it. His review: “It’s alright. I wouldn’t crave it.” He too found the cardamom flavor a bit strong.
In the interest of allowing my “study participants” to be fully aware of the circumstances, I shared my “experiment” with my dining companions before dessert was served. The assessment of the guests was similar to mine – they liked the flavor combination, but thought it would be better with a bit less cardamom. They, however, thought it was a perfectly good dessert.
All in all, I’d say there is no surprise why so many folks are impressed with Mr. Yosses. The bars are a great alternative to cookies and I think would be a great thing to take to a school function where kids and parents have traditionally expected a dessert, but a healthier alternative might be appreciated. I would have been thrilled to get these as our post-game treat during my adolescent soccer career instead of a packaged store cookie, but my husband would probably have picked the chocolate cream sandwich cookie from the store. I think they’d also make a great alternative to the cookie plates that sometimes appear at 3pm meetings and lectures around some hospitals and universities. And I’m sure they’d be a welcome addition to a BBQ or pot-luck, though some folks may choose the slice and bake cookies first.